News Times 7
Otherअध्यात्मक्राइमटॉप न्यूज़दुर्घटनाबड़ी-खबरबिचारबिडियोब्रे़किंग न्यूज़मनोरंजनराजनीतिशिक्षासंपादकीय

The Supreme Court’s jurisprudence on reservations has gaps

Last month, a Supreme Court judgment, holding that there was no fundamental right to reservation under the Indian Constitution, caused something of a furore. The judgment was criticised, and there were calls for a Bharatbandh in protest. In terms of law, however, there was nothing particularly surprising or novel about the judgment. The court only reiterated the existing position of law, according to which, reservations are provided at the discretion of the government; if it chooses not to do so, the court cannot compel it otherwise.
Although this position of law is a settled one, it is nonetheless at odds with certain other principles at the heart of the constitutional vision of equality. To understand this, we need to undertake a brief historical tour. Until 1976, the Supreme Court had consistently held that the constitutional guarantee of equality before the law referred to “formal equality” — of simply ensuring that on its face, the law did not discriminate between sections of people. Article 16(4) of the Constitution — which allowed the State to make reservations in public employment — was considered to be an “exception” to the general “rule” of formal equality. Thus, it was interpreted narrowly.
In a 1976 judgment called NM Thomas, however, the Supreme Court transformed this understanding of equality. It held that the Constitution was committed to an idea of substantive equality, ie it had to take the actual circumstances of people into account when determining what constituted “equal treatment”.
In this context, on the face of it, “neutral” policies would violate the principle of equality if they treated people, in materially different circumstances, in the same fashion. Using this principle, the Supreme Court went on to hold that Article 16(4) was no longer an “exception” to the general rule of equality, but a “facet”, or “emphatic restatement” of it.

Advertisement

Related posts

देश में दिखेगा दूध पर भी महंगाई का असर,दूध समेत सभी डेयरी प्रोडक्ट्स हो सकते हैं महंगे

News Times 7

बिहार में 251 फीट लंबा कांवर लोगो के लिए अजूबा ,बाबा गरीबनाथ का जलाभिषेक करने निकल पड़े शिव भक्‍त

News Times 7

युगांडा,जर्मनी, स्वीडन की तर्ज पर दिल्ली वालों को भी मिलेगा हेल्थ कार्ड, देश में अपनी तरह का यह अलग और इकलौता सिस्टम होगा

News Times 7

Leave a Comment

टॉप न्यूज़
ब्रेकिंग न्यूज़